Key Indicator Summary - Double Dip For Housing?
Written by Jonathan Dienhart   
03.25.2010
There was once a time that the financial markets frantically reacted to any news that came out of the housing market. Recently, there hasn’t been nearly the reaction in equity markets one might expect from the record low new home sales in February, lackluster resale data, an increase in mortgage delinquencies, and the continued slowdown in building activity. The National Association of Realtors reported that existing home sales fell for the third consecutive month in February while Census Bureau data showed that new home sales fell for four straight months to a new record low.

On Thursday, the Office of the Comptroller (OCC) and the Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS) released a report that showed the percentage of mortgages that remain current fell for the seventh consecutive quarter at the end of 2009 caused by a 21.1% jump in mortgages that were 90 days or more past due. To combat the rise in defaults, the government introduced a $14 billion plan on Friday to help homeowners who are currently “underwater” with a new FHA refinancing program..

Those predicting a “W” shaped recovery in housing seem to be having their forecast play out, with several months of deterioration of a housing market that looked like it was on the road to stabilization last year. While the extended federal tax credit for home purchases may drive some additional sales activity in March and April before it expires, so far anecdotal evidence from home builders on March home sales has not been particularly good. The state of California also has rolled out a new tax credit program for the year, but if these incentive programs fail to generate an increase in purchase activity, the housing market may be in for yet another rough year.

Resale volume is being driven in no small part by foreclosure and REO sales activity, leaving new home builders left to compete in a brutally competitive pricing environment. With most economists expecting mortgage rates to begin an inevitable slow rise this year, and unemployment rates across the country remaining stubbornly high, it’s hard to make the case that anything resembling a substantial housing recovery is in the cards for 2010.

Although stocks pulled back in afternoon trading on Thursday to close roughly flat, they opened trading on Friday broadly higher driven by economic reports that showed economic growth in the 4th quarter of 2009 being revised slightly lower and consumer sentiment roughly unchanged from the previous month. All three major indexes have now pared gains and trade roughly flat in early afternoon trading on Friday with the broader S&P 500 index down 0.1% to 1,164. The blue-chip Dow Jones Industrial Index flirted with 11,000 before pulling back in the past few sessions which might suggest some cautiousness in the market following a bullish seven-week run.

Driving market enthusiasm this week was news that the European Union has shown more commitment to support Greece in its financial woes which alleviated some fears that may have sparked another global financial meltdown. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke also stated that economic conditions were improving while reiterating the Fed’s stance on keeping economic stimulus efforts in place as needed. A drop in initial unemployment claims this past week ignited further enthusiasm that labor market conditions are steadily improving.

While recent market focus has shifted towards a resurgence in the economy and employment data, the government took a big step on Friday to address the housing market which has taken a backseat in the headlines. The condition of the U.S. housing market remains a huge factor in an economic recovery and until foreclosures subside and home prices stabilize, the state of the U.S. economy will remain uncertain. Inclement weather may have negatively impacted home sales in the first two months of the year but expect activity to pick up in March and April before the expiration of the homebuyer tax credit. After all the government intervention to keep housing afloat, it will be very important to see if the housing market can stand on its own two feet when the tax credit expires and interest rates start to steadily move higher as the year goes on.

The Economy
Economic growth was revised slightly lower in the final fourth quarter GDP report. Final estimates showed that gross domestic product increased 5.6% which is slightly lower than the previous estimate of 5.9% growth. Growth remained much faster than the 2.2% pace recorded in the third quarter and marked the second straight quarter in which the economy expanded. Consumer, business, and government spending were all revised slightly weaker in the final report.

Consumer sentiment remained unchanged from the previous month. Consumers remain wary of an economic recovery as nearly 1 out of every 10 Americans is still unemployed. The University of Michigan/Reuters consumer sentiment survey recorded a reading of 73.6 in March which was unchanged from the previous month but up 28% from the same year-ago period. Improving sentiment amongst consumers will be instrumental in an economic recovery since consumer spending now accounts for over two-thirds of the economy. However, high levels of unemployment and the lack of jobs currently available will likely keep most consumers hesitant.

 


Initial unemployment claims fell for the third time in the past four weeks. Initial claims dropped by 14,000 to a seasonally-adjusted figure of 442,000 for the week ending March 20. Jobless claims have trended lower in the past several weeks which suggest that the employment situation may finally be stabilizing.

Housing Market
Home sales in both the new and existing home markets posted declines again in February. Inclement weather was again to blame for the slowdown in activity. However, the lack of activity in the first two months of the year may have created some pent up demand for the coming months before the expiration of the homebuyer tax credit at the end of April.

New home sales fell 2.2% in February to a seasonally-adjusted annual pace of 308,000 units. This was the fourth consecutive month that new home sales volume has declined while hitting a new all-time low. However, new home sales for the previous three months were revised higher by 3,000 units. Median new home prices in February rebounded to $220,500 from an upwardly revised price of $207,900 in January. Prices are up 6.1% from the previous month and are 5.1% higher than they were this time last year. This is the highest median new home prices have been since May 2009.
In February, new home inventories increased slightly from the previous month to 233,000 units on a non-seasonally adjusted basis. This is the first time since May 2007 that new home inventory has recorded a monthly increase on a non-seasonally adjusted basis. Seasonally-adjusted inventory of unsold homes increased for the second straight month in February to 236,000 units. A record-low sales pace along with a slight increase in inventory levels pushed months of inventory back up to 9.2 months which is the highest it has been since May 2009.

Existing home sales fell for the third straight month in February to a seasonally-adjusted annual rate of 5,020,000 units which is a 0.6% decline from January levels. Existing single-family home sales eased 1.4% from last month to 4,370,000 units while existing condo and co-op sales increased 4.8% from January levels to 650,000 units. Median existing home prices rebounded slightly after reaching their lowest levels since May 2002. In February, the median sales price for an existing home increased to $165,100 from a revised $164,900 in January.

After declining for six consecutive months, existing home inventory jumped 9.5% in February to 3,589,000 units. This is the highest level of existing home inventory on the market since September 2009. Inclement weather in the past couple of months may have kept buyers from listing their properties for sale while many sellers are also trying to take advantage of the anticipated increase in demand before the homebuyer tax credit expires at the end of April..

National average mortgage rates increased from the previous week to 4.99% in the latest Primary Mortgage Market Survey released weekly by Freddie Mac on March 24th. This is the fourth straight week that the 30-year fixed rates have averaged under 5.0%. In the week ending March 19th, the MBA’s seasonally-adjusted purchase index increased 2.7% from the previous week but was still down 15.05% compared to the same time last year. Overall mortgage application activity declined 4.2% over the past week due to a drop in refinance activity.

For market-level data and analysis please visit our website at http://www.hwmarketintelligence.com. For more detailed information on the indicators discussed in this key indicator alert, please visit the following links:


Employment Growth Existing Home Sales
Unemployment Rate Existing Home Inventory
Real GDP Growth Existing Home Affordability
Consumer Confidence Median Price New Home
Purchase Mortgage Applications New Home Sales
Mortgage Rates New Home Inventory
Median Price Existing Home New Home Affordability Ratio
There are no comments for this item.
Please login or register to post comments.
J! Reactions Commenting Software
General Site License
Copyright © 2006 S. A. DeCaro
 
< Prev   Next >